AthenaHQ vs Geotally (2026): Free Tiers, Then $295 vs $19
AthenaHQ is one of the strongest tools in this category — a genuine free tier, the widest engine set here, and content agents that act, not just monitor. The wedge is the paid jump: AthenaHQ's Starter is $295/month; Geotally's is $19.
TL;DR verdict
Pick AthenaHQ ifyou want the broadest engine coverage — including Grok and Google AI Mode — plus an action layer: content optimization agents, robots.txt and llms.txt management, and a citation engine. If you'll use those and can absorb $295/month, it's a credible pick.
Pick Geotally ifyou want six-engine visibility at a low paid entry. Both free tiers include Claude; the gap opens once you outgrow free. Honest tradeoff: AthenaHQ does more — more engines, more integrations, more automation — and charges for it. We're focused visibility tracking at $19/month.
| Feature | Geotally | AthenaHQ |
|---|---|---|
| Free tier | Yes, no card, incl. Claude | Yes — 300 credits + $25 credit, incl. Claude |
| Paid entry | $19/mo (Starter) | $295/mo Starter (~$245 annual) |
| Engines covered | 6 | 8–9 (adds Grok, Google AI Mode) |
| Claude coverage | Yes, incl. free | Yes, incl. free |
| Usage model | Prompts: 5 / 15 / 50 by tier | Credits: 1 = 1 AI response; 3,600/mo on Starter |
| Action layer | Tracking + reporting | Content agents, robots.txt/llms.txt, citation engine |
| Integrations | White-label PDF (Agency) | GA4/GSC, Shopify/Webflow, API, CSV export |
| Buying | Self-serve online checkout | Self-serve (Free/Starter), sales (Enterprise) |
| Publish fixes to WordPress | Yes — one-click article publishing + win tracking | No publishing workflow (tracking/analysis only) |
Competitor details are from their public pages and third-party reviews, verified July 2026. Check the vendor's site for current terms.
Where Geotally wins
- Lower paid entry: once you outgrow free, our Starter is $19/month; AthenaHQ's first paid tier is $295.
- Simpler pricing — flat prompt tiers (5 / 15 / 50) instead of metering every AI response as a credit.
- White-label PDF on Agency: client-ready reports on our $349 tier.
- Flat engine coverage: six engines on every plan.
Where AthenaHQ wins
- Broadest engine coverage: eight to nine engines, including Grok and Google AI Mode, which Geotally doesn't track.
- A real action layer — content optimization agents, robots.txt and llms.txt management, and a citation engine, not just monitoring.
- A matching free tier: 300 credits, a $25 credit, and Claude coverage compete with ours head-on.
- Deeper integrations: GA4/GSC, Shopify/Webflow, API access, and CSV export.
- Pedigree — built by ex-Google Search and DeepMind founders; a G2 High Performer badge for Spring 2026 (confirm on their site).
Frequently asked questions
How much does AthenaHQ cost?
A free Essential tier (300 credits plus a $25 credit), then Starter at $295/mo (about $245 on annual billing) with 3,600 credits, then custom Enterprise. Some reviews cite different tier names; the live page lists Essential, Starter, and Enterprise. Geotally starts at $19/mo.
Does AthenaHQ have a free plan?
Yes — a genuine free tier with 300 credits, a $25 credit, and Claude coverage. Geotally also has a free tier with no card. The difference shows at the paid step: $295/mo versus $19/mo.
What engines does AthenaHQ track?
Eight to nine: ChatGPT, Perplexity, Google AI Overviews, AI Mode, Gemini, Claude, Copilot, and Grok, with more on request. Geotally tracks six and doesn't include Grok or AI Mode.
Is AthenaHQ worth it?
If you want action agents and the widest engine set — including Grok and AI Mode — and can absorb $295/month, it's a strong tool. If you mainly need visibility tracking, $19/month covers six engines.
What's an AthenaHQ alternative?
Geotally tracks six engines from $19/mo with a free tier that also includes Claude. You trade AthenaHQ's broader engine set and content agents for a lower paid entry and simpler, prompt-based pricing.
Track your brand visibility across 6 AI engines. Start free — no card or license required.
Start free